War Crimes Safari › Incidents › 19

19Premature babies left to decompose in the ICU of al-Nasr Children's Hospital

Evacuated ~10 Nov 2023; bodies filmed 27 Nov 2023

Around 10 November 2023, as Israeli ground forces encircled Gaza City's al-Nasr Children's Hospital, staff say they were ordered out within minutes under fire, with tanks at the gates and no ambulances able to reach them, and left behind premature infants on ventilators who could not be moved without life support; Médecins Sans Frontières relayed a volunteer nurse's account that day, and its deputy medical coordinator told The Washington Post that five babies were left "alone in the intensive care on the machines." On 27 November, during the truce, Al Mashhad reporter Mohamed Baalousha filmed the decomposing remains of four to five infants still in their beds, which CNN geolocated to the hospital's ICU and two independent forensic pathologists told NBC News were consistent with roughly two weeks of abandonment; the ICRC said it received evacuation requests but was never involved, and the IDF said it "did not operate inside the Al-Nasr hospital" and called the allegations "a perverse exploitation of innocent lives."

⚠ Undisputed: the infants' remains were in al-Nasr's ICU and decomposed there. Disputed: how many (four or five), whether all were alive and on oxygen when staff left, and who promised the ambulances that never came. The Washington Institute, a pro-Israel think tank whose piece ranks highly in search (marked here as propaganda), attacked the Post's reliance on one anonymous nurse and an undisclosed family tie between its reporter and the videographer; the Post has not retracted, and none of it explains how the babies came to rot in their beds.
🇮🇱 Official responseIDF statement: "did not operate inside the Al-Nasr hospital" (quoted by Algemeiner, 30 Nov 2023)
Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Nasr_Children%27s_Hospital
⚑ Excuse: on file 🕊 Response: condemnation & concern⚖ Sanctions: none✈ Arms exports: uninterrupted

Anatomy of an excuse

Anatomy of an Excuse: six denial claims about the al-Nasr babies, each answered with a question of reasoning — an intact ceiling does not establish the babies were safe; imagining an evacuation does not prove it was possible; blaming absent caregivers requires evidence; a possibility is not a timeline; missing autopsies cannot confirm a preferred explanation; an accusation of motive is not proof of motive.
Propaganda training: six claims circulated to deny the al-Nasr babies, and why none of them hold. Quoted claims are not verified facts; illustrations are symbolic. Inspired by @CaliDreamingof on X

The record — 15 sources

Date, publication and headline for each source, as the source itself published them. Sorted by publication date. 13 of 15 dated; a blank means the publisher's page didn't expose it, and we don't guess.

DatePublicationHeadline
2023-11-13Al Jazeera‘Patients are dying’: What we know about Gaza hospitals under Israeli siege
2023-11-29AJ+ (Al Jazeera) — videoInfants were left for dead after Israel forcibly evacuated al-Nasr hospital
2023-11-29Middle East EyeFive dead babies discovered in Gaza hospital
2023-11-29TRT World — videoDecomposed bodies of premature babies found in Gaza’s Al Nasr Children’s Hospital
2023-11-29The Electronic IntifadaIsraeli military left Palestinian infants to die
2023-11-29Palestine ChronicleFive Dead Premature Babies Discovered in Gaza Hospital
2023-12-01Human Rights WatchBirth and Death Intertwined in Gaza Strip
2023-12-02NBC NewsAbandoned babies found decomposing in Gaza hospital weeks after it was evacuated
2023-12-03The Washington PostIsrael’s assault forced a nurse to leave babies behind. They were found decomposing.
2023-12-04The Daily BeastDecomposing Babies Found in Abandoned Gaza Hospital: Report
2023-12-06Common DreamsUS Official Won't Call Forced Abandonment of Gaza Newborns a War Crime | Common Dreams
2023-12-08CNNInfants found dead and decomposing in evacuated Gaza ICU. Here’s what we know | CNN
2024-03-09Anadolu AgencyIsraeli army left infants to die in Al-Nasr Children's Hospital: Palestinian doctor
—Institute for Palestine Studies — health-sector recordheadline not retrievedgazahcsector.palestine-studies.org
—The Washington Institute (WINEP)Once Again, a “Palestinian Babies” Story Merits a Washington Post Apologypropaganda