War Crimes Safari › Propaganda desk › P5

P5“Outrage should be directed at Hamas”: a 2020 rocket video, reposted for Gaza's 2026 floods

Israel MFA post: 9 Nov 2026 · footage aired by Al Jazeera: 13 Sep 2020 · pipes described by Sinwar: 4 Nov 2019 · Last updated

On 9 November 2026, as the first winter storm flooded Gaza's tent camps, Israel's Foreign Ministry posted a 64-second Al-Qassam Brigades video of men digging up pipes and turning them into rockets, writing that “when the rains come and sewage floods Gaza's streets, outrage should be directed at Hamas.” The footage is genuine Hamas propaganda, but it isn't new: it matches an Al Jazeera documentary aired on 13 September 2020 and already circulated in October 2023 as “EU-funded water pipes”, and the pipes are the ones Yahya Sinwar said in 2019 were dug out of the former Israeli settlements, not Gaza's sewers or storm drains. The UN and aid groups attribute this week's flooding to a water, sewage and drainage network damaged in the war, pumps without fuel or spare parts, and tents held outside Gaza; Israel says 91,000 tents have gone in and blames Hamas.

True ingredients, false recipe. Hamas did turn pipes into rockets, and bragged about it on camera; under a ban on importing metal, it chose rockets. But the pipes in this video came out of the sand of the former settlements years before this war, and the sewage in the tents this week comes from a network damaged in the war and pumps without fuel. Blaming 2020 footage for 2026 floods is the propaganda move. Pretending Hamas never spent scarce metal on rockets is the opposite one.
⚠ Check it yourself: the Al-Qassam watermark (الإعلام العسكري) is in almost every frame; Arabic coverage of the Al Jazeera episode is dated 13 September 2020; a repost of the same footage was already on X on 19 December 2024, by the timestamp in its media ID. The MFA's post text is archived here with hashes of the video as we downloaded it.
🇮🇱 Official responseIsrael MFA on X, 9 Nov 2026: the post and its video

Four frames, one watermark

Four frames from the video Israel's Foreign Ministry posted on 9 November 2026: a crane lifting long white pipes onto a truck in sandy open ground; a stack of wide pipes; a masked man cutting a buried pipe in a trench; a diver underwater. Each frame carries the Al-Qassam Military Media watermark at the lower left.
Frames at 0:01, 0:05, 0:09 and 0:33 of the video in Israel MFA's post. Lower left: the Al-Qassam Brigades' “Military Media” logo. Sandy open ground, not city streets; the diver matches the 2020 account of shells salvaged from First World War wrecks. Original post

The post

Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, on X, 9 November 2026, 17:00 UTC, two days into the storm (post, archived text):

“Palestinian Hamas's own videos show it digging up water pipes and turning them into rockets to attack Israel. Infrastructure meant to serve Gazans is sacrificed to fuel Hamas's war. When the rains come and sewage floods Gaza's streets, outrage should be directed at Hamas.”

It had about 126,000 views when we read it on 10 November. Reposts went further: one, with the same footage, said Hamas released the video on October 7th and that “Israel is not to blame for any flooding.” Its video file was already on X on 19 December 2024, by its media ID, so it wasn't new then either. verified

What the video shows

SceneWhat it isStatus
Crane trucks lifting long, wide pipes out of open sandy ground; men digging them out of trenchesPipe recovery in open land — dunes, scrub, no buildings or streets in frameverified
Workshops: pipes cut, cleaned, filled; finished rockets on racks under Qassam signageRocket productionverified
Divers underwater, lifting objects from a wreckMatches the 2020 Al Jazeera account of shells salvaged from two British warships sunk off Gaza in the First World Warreported
Night launches; closing montage with a fighter, flag and the Dome of the RockQassam propaganda framingverified
Watermark in almost every frameAl-Qassam Brigades “Military Media” (الإعلام العسكري)verified

How old it is

So this is at least the third outing for the same footage: 2020 as Hamas's boast, 2023 as “EU-funded pipes”, 2026 as the cause of the floods. We matched the scenes to the 2020 episode's published descriptions, not frame by frame to the broadcast itself, which we couldn't retrieve; we haven't seen the MEMRI clip the 2023 debunk cites. None of it shows anything that dates it to this war.

DateWhatSource
Aug–Sep 2005Israel withdraws from Gaza and evacuates its settlements, including the Gush Katif blochistorical record
4 Nov 2019Sinwar on Al-Aqsa TV: Qassam ran out of pipes for rockets; a farmer showed them irrigation lines left in Gush Katif, enough “for the next 10 years”World Israel News, citing MEMRI reported
13 Sep 2020Al Jazeera's “What Is Hidden Is Greater” (ما خفي أعظم) airs Qassam's account of its weapons: unexploded Israeli bombs, shells from sunken British warships, and settlement water linesArabi21 · QNN, 14 Sep · JNS, 24 Sep reported
11 Oct 2023Four days after October 7, the same kind of footage resurfaces with a new twist: The Daily Telegraph reports the EU funded water pipelines “that terrorists turned into rockets”; the claim spreads as “EU-funded water pipes”. The EU says it funds Hamas neither “directly or indirectly”The Telegraph, via PressReader reported
10 Nov 2023Debunk video by Wally Rashid, answering a post by Ben Shapiro: the clip was cut without its audio; he traces it to a 2020 MEMRI release with the original sound, in which a Qassam commander says the pipes are the old settlement lines, not EU-funded onesMiddle East Observer on X reported
19 Dec 2024The same footage on X, in a file whose media ID dates its uploadX media ID verified
9 Nov 2026Israel MFA posts a 64-second cut during the floodsIsrael MFA verified

Whose pipes?

Hamas, Al Jazeera and a pro-Israel outlet agree on where the pipes came from: settlement-era lines, buried in the sand after 2005. The Foreign Ministry's phrase is arguable, not invented — abandoned water lines could have served Gaza's farms — but nothing here is the sewage or storm-drain network now overflowing.

What is flooding Gaza this week

Same footage, different verbs

Each step drops a fact: first where the pipes came from, then when, then what they were. By the last version, 2020 footage of settlement pipes has become proof about a 2026 storm.

How to weigh it

The record — 9 sources

Date, publication and headline for each source, as the source itself published them, grouped by stance. Sorted by publication date. 7 of 9 dated; a blank means the publisher's page didn't expose it, and we don't guess.

DatePublicationHeadline
Mainstream, international, UN & NGO · 7
2020-09-13Arabi21 (Arabic)تحقيق للجزيرة: "القسام" وجدت مئات القذائف بسفينتين غارقتين
2023-10-11The Daily Telegraph (print edition, via PressReader)EU funded water pipelines that terrorists turned into rockets
2026-11-08The Jerusalem Post (Amir Bohbot)COGAT rejects Hamas allegations of unpreparedness for winter rain, says 91,000 new tents delivered
2026-11-09UN NewsChildren among the dead as heavy rains flood tents and shelters in Gaza
2026-11-09International Rescue CommitteeAt least 5 dead, 26,000 households flooded as people in Gaza face fourth winter in tents
—The Times of IsraelHamas said to retrieve ammunition from British WWI warship sunk off Gaza coast
—Jewish NewsBoard of Peace warns Gaza winter aid ‘insufficient’ despite 8,200 truck deliveries
Palestinian & pro-Palestinian · 2
2020-09-14Quds News NetworkHamas reveals new sources of its weapons
2023-11-10Middle East Observer on X — Wally Rashid's debunk videoWally Rashid exposing Ben Shapiro the fraud

Official government sources — 3 sources

Exercise extra caution. The Israeli government's own statements and the pro-Israel advocacy that amplifies them, kept apart from the record above. Israel is a party to the war, its public-diplomacy budget roughly quintupled to $730 million in 2026, and its first accounts of several incidents here were later contradicted — so read them as one side's case, and check them. Labels describe each source's stance; propaganda marks what we cite as an example of denial, not as evidence.

DatePublicationHeadline
Israeli government & military · 1
2026-11-09Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs (@IsraelMFA) on XPalestinian Hamas's own videos show it digging up water pipes and turning them into rockets to attack Israel.propaganda
Pro-Israel advocacy · 2
2019-11-17World Israel News, citing MEMRIHamas leader: ‘We make rockets from leftover Israeli irrigation pipes’
2020-09-24JNSAl Jazeera airs documentary about Hamas's missile industry