P5“Outrage should be directed at Hamas”: a 2020 rocket video, reposted for Gaza's 2026 floods
- The video is real — and Hamas's own. The Al-Qassam “Military Media” watermark runs through it; its scenes match Al Jazeera's “What Is Hidden Is Greater”, aired 13 September 2020.
- The pipes aren't Gaza's sewers. Sinwar said in 2019, and Qassam told Al Jazeera in 2020, that they came out of the ground in the former settlements, left behind in 2005.
- The floods have nearer causes. UN: thousands of families flooded, pumps without fuel, 150,000 tents waiting outside Gaza. Israel: 91,000 tents delivered, Hamas to blame.
On 9 November 2026, as the first winter storm flooded Gaza's tent camps, Israel's Foreign Ministry posted a 64-second Al-Qassam Brigades video of men digging up pipes and turning them into rockets, writing that “when the rains come and sewage floods Gaza's streets, outrage should be directed at Hamas.” The footage is genuine Hamas propaganda, but it isn't new: it matches an Al Jazeera documentary aired on 13 September 2020 and already circulated in October 2023 as “EU-funded water pipes”, and the pipes are the ones Yahya Sinwar said in 2019 were dug out of the former Israeli settlements, not Gaza's sewers or storm drains. The UN and aid groups attribute this week's flooding to a water, sewage and drainage network damaged in the war, pumps without fuel or spare parts, and tents held outside Gaza; Israel says 91,000 tents have gone in and blames Hamas.
Four frames, one watermark

The post
Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, on X, 9 November 2026, 17:00 UTC, two days into the storm (post, archived text):
“Palestinian Hamas's own videos show it digging up water pipes and turning them into rockets to attack Israel. Infrastructure meant to serve Gazans is sacrificed to fuel Hamas's war. When the rains come and sewage floods Gaza's streets, outrage should be directed at Hamas.”
It had about 126,000 views when we read it on 10 November. Reposts went further: one, with the same footage, said Hamas released the video on October 7th and that “Israel is not to blame for any flooding.” Its video file was already on X on 19 December 2024, by its media ID, so it wasn't new then either. verified
What the video shows
| Scene | What it is | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Crane trucks lifting long, wide pipes out of open sandy ground; men digging them out of trenches | Pipe recovery in open land — dunes, scrub, no buildings or streets in frame | verified |
| Workshops: pipes cut, cleaned, filled; finished rockets on racks under Qassam signage | Rocket production | verified |
| Divers underwater, lifting objects from a wreck | Matches the 2020 Al Jazeera account of shells salvaged from two British warships sunk off Gaza in the First World War | reported |
| Night launches; closing montage with a fighter, flag and the Dome of the Rock | Qassam propaganda framing | verified |
| Watermark in almost every frame | Al-Qassam Brigades “Military Media” (الإعلام العسكري) | verified |
How old it is
So this is at least the third outing for the same footage: 2020 as Hamas's boast, 2023 as “EU-funded pipes”, 2026 as the cause of the floods. We matched the scenes to the 2020 episode's published descriptions, not frame by frame to the broadcast itself, which we couldn't retrieve; we haven't seen the MEMRI clip the 2023 debunk cites. None of it shows anything that dates it to this war.
| Date | What | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Aug–Sep 2005 | Israel withdraws from Gaza and evacuates its settlements, including the Gush Katif bloc | historical record |
| 4 Nov 2019 | Sinwar on Al-Aqsa TV: Qassam ran out of pipes for rockets; a farmer showed them irrigation lines left in Gush Katif, enough “for the next 10 years” | World Israel News, citing MEMRI reported |
| 13 Sep 2020 | Al Jazeera's “What Is Hidden Is Greater” (ما خفي أعظم) airs Qassam's account of its weapons: unexploded Israeli bombs, shells from sunken British warships, and settlement water lines | Arabi21 · QNN, 14 Sep · JNS, 24 Sep reported |
| 11 Oct 2023 | Four days after October 7, the same kind of footage resurfaces with a new twist: The Daily Telegraph reports the EU funded water pipelines “that terrorists turned into rockets”; the claim spreads as “EU-funded water pipes”. The EU says it funds Hamas neither “directly or indirectly” | The Telegraph, via PressReader reported |
| 10 Nov 2023 | Debunk video by Wally Rashid, answering a post by Ben Shapiro: the clip was cut without its audio; he traces it to a 2020 MEMRI release with the original sound, in which a Qassam commander says the pipes are the old settlement lines, not EU-funded ones | Middle East Observer on X reported |
| 19 Dec 2024 | The same footage on X, in a file whose media ID dates its upload | X media ID verified |
| 9 Nov 2026 | Israel MFA posts a 64-second cut during the floods | Israel MFA verified |
Whose pipes?
- Sinwar, 2019: “the pipes that the occupier left behind when it left the Gaza Strip” — irrigation lines from Israeli farms in Gush Katif (via MEMRI).
- Qassam, via Al Jazeera, 2020: old water pipelines “previously used to steal Gaza's groundwater and pump it to illegal settlements” (QNN's summary).
- JNS, 2020: “metal water pipes left behind by Israel when it unilaterally withdrew from Gaza in 2005” (JNS).
- Israel MFA, 2026: “water pipes … infrastructure meant to serve Gazans.”
Hamas, Al Jazeera and a pro-Israel outlet agree on where the pipes came from: settlement-era lines, buried in the sand after 2005. The Foreign Ministry's phrase is arguable, not invented — abandoned water lines could have served Gaza's farms — but nothing here is the sewage or storm-drain network now overflowing.
What is flooding Gaza this week
- The storm: from 7 November. At least five people, three of them children, killed when a sand embankment collapsed on tents west of Deir al-Balah; about 26,000 households asked for help; more than 6,000 family shelters destroyed; water 1.5 metres deep in places (UN News, citing OCHA). reported
- The UN and aid groups: “much of Gaza's water, sewage and drainage network was damaged during the war”; pumps are failing without fuel, engine oil and spare parts; aid groups hold about 2,800 tents in Gaza against a need of 121,000, while more than 150,000 wait outside; they need Israeli permission to bring in pumps, vacuum trucks and machinery (IRC, UN). reported
- Israel: security officials say COGAT, the Board of Peace and the UN brought in 91,000 new tents, tarpaulins and thousands of truckloads of clothes and blankets; that Hamas exploits aid to rearm; and that materials for permanent rebuilding and mobile homes stay out until Hamas disarms (Jerusalem Post, 8 Nov). reported
- The Board of Peace itself called the winter aid “insufficient” and pressed Israel to let more in (Jewish News). reported
Same footage, different verbs
- Qassam / Al Jazeera, 2020: the resistance recycled the occupation's leftovers under siege.
- Sinwar, 2019: the brothers removed from the ground what the occupier left behind.
- JNS, 2020: the terrorist group salvaged pipes left by Israel.
- Israel MFA, 2026: Hamas is digging up water pipes; infrastructure is sacrificed; outrage should be directed at Hamas.
- A repost, 2026: Hamas dug up the drainage system, released it on October 7th; Israel is not to blame for any flooding.
Each step drops a fact: first where the pipes came from, then when, then what they were. By the last version, 2020 footage of settlement pipes has become proof about a 2026 storm.
How to weigh it
- The fair point. Hamas built rockets from whatever metal it could find and boasted about it; the choice of rockets over anything else is its own, and Sinwar said so on television.
- The unfair one. The video doesn't show Gaza's sewers or drains, and nothing ties it to this winter. Using it to answer “why are the tents flooding?” swaps the question.
- Both sides have a case on aid. Israel's 91,000 tents and the UN's 150,000 tents held outside can both be true. The dispute is about need and pace, and only a joint, published count would settle it.
- Why it's on this desk. The Foreign Ministry is a party to the war; its post uses real footage to make a claim the footage doesn't support. That is what extra caution is for.
The record — 9 sources
Date, publication and headline for each source, as the source itself published them, grouped by stance. Sorted by publication date. 7 of 9 dated; a blank means the publisher's page didn't expose it, and we don't guess.
Official government sources — 3 sources
Exercise extra caution. The Israeli government's own statements and the pro-Israel advocacy that amplifies them, kept apart from the record above. Israel is a party to the war, its public-diplomacy budget roughly quintupled to $730 million in 2026, and its first accounts of several incidents here were later contradicted — so read them as one side's case, and check them. Labels describe each source's stance; propaganda marks what we cite as an example of denial, not as evidence.
| Date | Publication | Headline | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Israeli government & military · 1 | |||
| 2026-11-09 | Palestinian Hamas's own videos show it digging up water pipes and turning them into rockets to attack Israel.propaganda | ||
| Pro-Israel advocacy · 2 | |||
| 2019-11-17 | Hamas leader: ‘We make rockets from leftover Israeli irrigation pipes’ | ||
| 2020-09-24 | Al Jazeera airs documentary about Hamas's missile industry | ||