War Crimes Safari › Propaganda desk › P1

P1HonestReporting: an Israel advocacy group, in its own words

Founded October 2000 · About page read 26 Oct 2026 · Last updated

HonestReporting presents itself as a media watchdog, but its own mission statement limits its concern for fairness in journalism to coverage "as it impacts Israel"; it was founded in October 2000 by Shaul Rosenblatt of Aish HaTorah UK, has been led since 2022 by former AIPAC regional director Jacki Alexander, and critics including Reporters Without Borders and the Canadian Association of Journalists have described its campaigns against reporters as intimidation. In November 2023 it insinuated that Gaza photojournalists working for AP, Reuters, CNN and The New York Times had advance knowledge of the 7 October attack; the outlets showed their photos were taken after it began, Israeli politicians called for the photographers to be targeted, and HonestReporting's executive director then conceded the group had no evidence and had only "raised questions."

So honest about its bias that it put it in the first paragraph.
⚠ HonestReporting says it is not affiliated with any government or party; per Wikipedia, in 2024 it took part in a strategy session with Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar on a $150 million state “public diplomacy” initiative. Word counts are of the About page's main text (mission, principles and strategy) as read on 26 Oct 2026.
📄 Official responseHonestReporting's own About page — mission statement and guiding principles
Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org/wiki/HonestReporting

Exhibit A: the About page

Screenshot of HonestReporting's About Us page, mission statement and guiding principles, with every mention of Israel, Israeli, Holocaust, antisemitism and Jewish boxed in red.
honestreporting.com/about — mission statement and guiding principles. Highlights ours. Original page

The record — 45 sources

Date, publication and headline for each source, as the source itself published them, grouped by stance. Sorted by publication date. 38 of 45 dated; a blank means the publisher's page didn't expose it, and we don't guess.

DatePublicationHeadline
Mainstream, international, UN & NGO · 45
2000-10-06The Wall Street JournalCarnage for the Cameras(via Wikipedia)
2001-02-22The GuardianComment: Media manipulators
2007-10-11The Canadian Jewish NewsFilms at Concordia cause controversy(via Wikipedia)
2011-11-04National PostJonathan Kay on Stéphane Gendron, Quebec's Israel-hater en chef | National Post
2012-01-06CBC NewsQuebec mayor under fire for anti-Israel remarks | CBC News
2012-08-08The Times of IsraelGuardian: We were wrong to call Tel Aviv Israel's capital(via Wikipedia)
2012-11-16news.com.au'PALLYWOOD': Israel accuses enemies of fake casualties(via Wikipedia)
2014-08-25HaaretzTime Retracts Claim That Israeli Troops Harvested Palestinian Organs(via Wikipedia)
2022-05-25Religion News ServiceHonestReporting announces appointment of Gil Hoffman as new executive director(via Wikipedia)
2022-08-22Sky News AustraliaThe Guardian and the ABC join global media outlets in cutting ties with anti-Semitic freelance journalist Fady Hanona(via Wikipedia)
2022-10-19Fox NewsReuters rescinds award from Palestinian journalist following surfaced social media posts praising Hitler
2022-10-19Ynet NewsPalestinian journalist stripped of award for pro-Hitler remarks
2022-10-19The Jewish ChronicleReuters retracts award from Palestinian journalist after ‘friends with Hitler’ comments surface - The Jewish Chronicle
2022-10-21Arab NewsPalestinian journalist stripped of award over antisemitic comments(via Wikipedia)
2022-11-19MSNMSN
2022-12-24TukoIdris Muktar says he lost dream job at CNN over tweets he posted 10 years ago
2023-11-09CNNNews outlets deny prior knowledge of Hamas attack after Israeli government demands answers over misleading report | CNN Business
2023-11-09Al JazeeraNews organisations reject allegations of complicity in October 7 attacks
2023-11-09HaaretzNews Agencies Dispute Israeli Allegations of Complicity in Hamas Massacre(via Wikipedia)
2023-11-09The ForwardNews outlets deny watchdog's allegations that they were tipped to Hamas attacks(via Wikipedia)
2023-11-09APMedia watchdog says it was just 'raising questions' with insinuations about photographers and Hamas(via Wikipedia)
2023-11-09ReutersReuters denies any suggestion it had prior knowledge of Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel(via Wikipedia)
2023-11-09The Washington PostNews organizations deny advance knowledge of Hamas attack(via Wikipedia)
2023-11-11Le MondePhotojournalists 'embedded' with Hamas on October 7: Heavy but unsubstantiated Israeli accusations(via Wikipedia)
2023-11-24International Media SupportHow an Israeli media watchdog’s unsubstantiated allegations has put a price on Palestinian journalists’ heads | IMS
2024-10-22La ConverseINVESTIGATION — Journalists denounce pressure from the pro-Israel group Honest Reporting Canada | Articles | La Converse
2024-10-24The MapleJournalists Urged To Report Threats Received After Pro-Israel Campaigns
2024-12-26Jewish InsiderIsrael's foreign minister is looking for a way to spend $150 million on public diplomacy
2025-01-24Toronto StarAssistant director of Honest Reporting facing charges in connection with Riverdale graffiti(via Wikipedia)
2025-01-28JTASenior employee of Canadian pro-Israel media watchdog charged for anti-Palestinian graffiti - Jewish Telegraphic Agency
2025-03-05Toronto StarCrown withdraws charges against Honest Reporting staffer over anti-Palestinian graffiti(via Wikipedia)
2025-03-27Forbidden StoriesFrom Slander to Exile: Photographer Yasser Qudih Targeted for Doing His Job
2025-07-27MisbarInside HonestReporting: The Israeli Watchdog Shaping Gaza War Coverage and Endangering Journalists
2025-09-30HaaretzIsrael approves 150-million-shekel boost to Foreign Ministry's hasbara budget(via Wikipedia)
2025-10-30Reporters Without Borders (RSF)SOCIAL - They smear media and promote mistrust of journalists
2025-11-21MisbarExploiting an Ai-Generated Image To Recycle the “Pallywood” Narrative and Deny the Murder of Muhammad Al-Durrah
2026-07-06Columbia Journalism ReviewWho Counts? The Committee to Protect Journalists’ role documenting members of the press killed in the Israel-Gaza war has made it a target.
2026-08-07Drop Site NewsPro-Israel Pressure Group Honest Reporting Received Grant from Knight Foundation
—The Australian Jewish NewsWatchdog accepts news orgs weren’t tipped off about Oct. 7: We just ‘raised questions’
—ReutersHonestReporting accepts news groups had no prior warning of Oct. 7 Hamas attack(via Wikipedia)
—Jewish News (UK)HonestReporting Launches UK Site(via Wikipedia)
—ProPublica Nonprofit ExplorerHonest Reporting Com Inc - Nonprofit Explorer - ProPublica
—i24NEWSi24NEWS
—UK Parliament (written evidence)FKN0047 - Evidence on Disinformation and 'fake news'(via Wikipedia)
—The Times of IsraelNY Times cuts ties with Gaza freelancer who called to kill Jews 'like Hitler did'(via Wikipedia)

Official government sources — 6 sources

Exercise extra caution. The Israeli government's own statements and the pro-Israel advocacy that amplifies them, kept apart from the record above. Israel is a party to the war, its public-diplomacy budget roughly quintupled to $730 million in 2026, and its first accounts of several incidents here were later contradicted — so read them as one side's case, and check them. Labels describe each source's stance; propaganda marks what we cite as an example of denial, not as evidence.

DatePublicationHeadline
Pro-Israel advocacy · 6
2011-08-03HonestReportingHR: Elevating Action Against the UK Media(via Wikipedia)propaganda
2015-09-30HonestReportingOn This Day: Al-Dura and the Advent of Pallywood(via Wikipedia)propaganda
2022-09-15HonestReportingHonestReporting Announces Appointment of Jacki Alexander as New Global CEO(via Wikipedia)propaganda
2025-08-21HonestReporting Canada — on Anas al-Sharif, after his killingToronto Star Reporter Downplays Terrorist Ties Of Palestinian Anas Al Sharif - Honest Reporting Canadapropaganda
—HonestReporting — About UsAbout Uspropaganda
—HonestReporting — on the Gaza toddler (card 06)How a False “Tortured Toddler” Narrative Spread Uncheckedpropaganda